By Owen
Davey
(Flying
Eye
Books, 2018)
I expose
my bias when I say I have a hard time finding nonfiction books for
children to recommend. Part of it is a chronic problem in the
publishing industry: books may pack a lot of information but they
lack in entertainment. Would a boy pick up this book if he weren’t
assigned a project on, say, Brazil or guinea pigs? If he did pick it
up for fun, would he actually read it or just peruse the pictures and
a few sidebars? A book may have compelling facts, but too often they
are
not compellingly presented. Too
many nonfiction books for young readers make me feel like I need to
buy some poster board and start covering it with facts that begin
with the phrase, “Did you know...?”
It’s
a good thing I didn’t glance at the back cover of Bonkers
about Beetles
because there it is again: “Did you know...?” (I
still can’t read the text that follows.) I’ll confess that I have
spent very little time thinking about beetles; to be sure, I’ve
never wanted to become a coleopterist (a person who studies these
creatures). Perhaps a true test of this book is whether or not I have
more interest in beetles after reading it. I’m still not going to
change careers, but at least I’ll give beetles a second glance.
Success!
The
language in the book is fairly simple and clear, providing for smooth
reading and comprehension for students in grade five. Owen Davey
provides plenty of pictures that support the text. In fact, the book
is crawling with brilliantly colored and patterned beetles, so much
so that it may be overwhelming. Does
the violin beetle, for instance, get its due with a single sentence
as compared to the mole beetle? Probably not.
Two
beetles—fireflies and ladybugs—are “Featured Creatures” and
given double-page spreads, making them stand out. Others getting
shorter shrift will be memorable based on how much their trivia facts
resonate with the individual reader. For example, I was drawn to the
fact that rove beetles resemble army ants and infiltrate ant colonies
to eat their young. Gross maybe but clever! Moreover, the iron-clad
beetle is well named—its exterior is so hardy, a person could step
on it without causing damage.
There’s
a conscious attempt to entertain the reader based on how facts are
grouped and presented. Page headings include “You Can’t Run, But
You Can Hide” and “Dress for Success”. The best of these
groupings may be “And the Award Goes to...” with honorees such as
the tiger beetle as the fastest (eight feet per second!), the cashew
stem girdler as most fashion-minded and the
bearded weevil whose “bushy whiskers” give it “the look of a
19th
century English gentleman.” (You
won’t find that on the Wikipedia page!)
I
do have a few quibbles with the book. When labeling the parts of a
beetle, numbers are somewhat ambiguously placed beside the particular
diagram. A simple line touching the intended part would add clarity
to a young reader who may confuse, say, the antennae with the front
legs. There
is a “Conservation” page about the importance of beetles but
there isn’t mention of the destructive nature of some, such as the
pine beetle. This would offer some balance. Finally, the index is
organized by scientific family rather than simply alphabetically.
This makes it more cumbersome to search for the page that mentioned
the violin beetle (Family Carabidae) or the horned dung beetle
(Family Scarabaeidae). That
said, I do think many young readers will be satisfied with Bonkers
about Beetles.
Mission accomplished.
No comments:
Post a Comment